Spread peanut butter onto one slice of bread and jelly onto another slice. Press together to make a sandwich.
Use a round cookie cutter to slice the crust off of the edges of the bread. Discard crust. If you do not have a cookie cutter, use the lid of the peanut butter or rim of glass.
Use a fork to seal together the edges of the sandwich (like you would a pie crust).
Preheat the air fryer for 5 minutes at 400 degrees.
Add the peanut butter and jelly sandwich to the air fryer basket and heat on Air Crisp/ Air Fryer at 400 degrees for four minutes.
Carefully remove Air Fried Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwiches from the air fryer and serve.
Notes
Please note Every Air Fryer Brand is different. We use the NINJA FOODI ALL IN ONE, and the timing is meant for that. When first making this sandwich, it is wise to test the air fryer and check the sandwich 1-2 minutes before the recommended time and 1-2 minutes after till desired golden brown crust.